New Franklin Roof Types: Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs vs. Shingles

In New Franklin, roof types are diverse, and understanding the nuances of different roofing styles is paramount. The dilemma between the classic asphalt shingles and the trending metal roofs is a common challenge for homeowners. 

This article serves as your beacon, guiding you through an exhaustive comparison encompassing lifespan, cost, maintenance, and architectural style. By the conclusion, you’ll possess the knowledge needed to make a sound decision for your home’s roofing. In New Franklin, roof types are plentiful, but a well-informed choice guarantees both resilience and visual appeal.

Also, at Pine Ridge Roofing we have experienced professionals who can help you choose the best roof type in New Franklin, OH. Schedule a free inspection and estimate to start your project.

Key Takeaways

  • Exploring the spectrum of New Franklin roof types reveals the superiority of metal roofs, offering durability, varied styles, and an array of colors at competitive costs. Meanwhile, asphalt shingles present a cost-effective option with a wide variety of styles. 
  • Consulting your insurance provider is crucial to comprehending coverage for both materials. Additionally, consider local weather conditions when deciding on the material. 
  • Pine Ridge Roofing provides invaluable professional guidance to facilitate the selection of the optimal roof type in New Franklin, Ohio, and the surrounding areas.
  • Get a Free Inspection

    Table of Contents

    New Franklin Roof Types - Asphalt Shingles: A Popular Choice

    New Franklin Roof Types

    In New Franklin, roof type preferences often lean towards asphalt shingles, recognized for their cost-effectiveness, durability, and a wide range of style choices. Typically made of a fiberglass mat embedded in asphalt, these materials serve as the standard for asphalt shingle roofs. Advancements in design have allowed asphalt shingles to provide roofs with depth and dimension, and they are now available in a variety of colors. 

    However, when considering important factors such as lifespan, cost, maintenance, and architectural style, how well do they fare?

    Average Lifespan

    With an average lifespan of around 30 years, asphalt shingles may not match up to the enduring quality of metal roofs. 

    Despite this, the enticing 50-year warranty, especially for premium-grade laminated asphalt fiberglass shingles, holds great appeal for numerous homeowners.

    Cost and Installation

    Cost-effectiveness remains a key driver behind the popularity of asphalt shingles in roofing projects. Variations in the cost of asphalt shingles are closely tied to the complexity of the installation process. 

    Professional roofers find asphalt shingles and rolled roofing relatively easy to install, following a procedure that includes laying felt paper, arranging the shingles, and securing them with nails. On the flip side, the choice of metal roofing often entails a higher price tag and necessitates specialized installation techniques.

    Maintenance and Repair

    Sustaining the durability and performance of asphalt shingles necessitates regular maintenance and timely repairs. The primary emphasis is typically on the underlying layer, where components like felt paper and nails may require occasional repair or replacement. The advised timeline for asphalt shingle replacement spans from 15 to 30 years, depending on variables like material quality and prevailing environmental conditions. 

    Conversely, metal roofs demand less frequent maintenance owing to their exceptional resistance to wear and harsh weather conditions. This durability advantage translates to fewer challenges for homeowners in the long term, thereby validating the higher initial cost of installing metal roofs.

    Architectural Style

    A variety of styles and colors are available for asphalt shingles, including basic, 3-tab, and architectural types. They can even simulate the appearance of wood shingles and slate, providing homeowners with numerous options to match their home’s architectural style.

    In addition to their affordability and durability, the wide range of styles and colors available for asphalt shingles ensures that homeowners can find the perfect match for their home’s exterior design. This versatility is one of the reasons why asphalt shingles continue to be a popular choice for homeowners in the roof type in New Franklin, Ohio.

    New Franklin Roof Types - Metal Roofs: A Durable Alternative

    New Franklin Roof Types

    While asphalt shingles have remained a popular choice over the years, metal roofs are becoming increasingly favored. 

    In New Franklin, roof type is most durable with options like Premier Ribbed Metal or standing seam metal roofing. These not only offer an extended lifespan but also present a contemporary and refined aesthetic. Installers can arrange them in diverse patterns, mimicking the appearance of other roofing materials like asphalt shingles. Moreover, the versatility of metal roofs extends to a wide array of colors, allowing homeowners to harmonize with the architectural style of their residences. 

    The comparison between metal roofs and asphalt shingles encompasses factors such as lifespan, cost, maintenance, and architectural appeal.

    Average Lifespan

    The enduring nature of metal roofs spans 40 to 70 years, shaped by variables like material selection and local weather conditions. 

    Delving deeper, the aluminum variant proudly clocks in at a formidable 50-year lifespan, while steel, the heavyweight, stakes its claim with an impressive potential of up to 70 years.

    Cost and Installation

    Metal roofs can be more expensive to install than asphalt shingles, depending on the size and type of metal roofing. Prices may vary due to the materials and labor involved in the installation process.

    However, given the longer lifespan and durability of metal roofs, many homeowners find that the higher initial cost is offset by long-term savings and reduced maintenance requirements.

    The installation process for metal roofs is generally more specialized and time-consuming compared to asphalt shingles. On average, asphalt shingles require 1 to 3 days to install, while metal roofs can take up to a week, with an installation time of 1 to 4 days. However, many metal roofs can be installed directly over an older roof without having to remove the existing roofing material, which can save time and effort during the installation process.

    Maintenance and Repair

    Metal roofs demand less frequent upkeep due to their inherent design, minimizing the requirement for flashing and rubber pipe boots. Furthermore, metal exhibits greater resistance to wear, reducing vulnerability to damage caused by harsh weather conditions compared to asphalt shingles. It is advisable to conduct maintenance on metal roofs at least once a year for optimal performance. Routine tasks for metal roof maintenance include:

    • Thorough inspection for any indications of damage or wear.
    • Removal of debris, such as leaves and branches, from the roof surface.
    • Clearance of gutters and downspouts to ensure proper drainage.
    • Verification and tightening of any loose fasteners or screws.
    • Application of a protective coating or sealant if deemed necessary.

    For safety precautions, it is recommended to enlist professional help for maintenance rather than attempting to access the roof independently. 

    In contrast, asphalt roofing systems, particularly roofing shingles, are more prone to damage from extreme weather conditions like hail, high winds, and heavy snow. Timely repairs and regular maintenance are imperative to ensure their durability and performance, potentially resulting in increased long-term costs for homeowners.

    Architectural Style

    Homeowners exploring metal roof options can choose from a variety of styles, including premier ribbed metal, standing seam metal, and corrugated metal. This extensive range empowers individuals to select a metal roof that not only complements their home’s architectural style but also ensures the durability and longevity synonymous with metal roofs.

    The durability and cost-effectiveness of premier ribbed metal roofing make it a standout choice. This material excels in facing harsh conditions like strong winds, hail, heavy snowfall, and extreme weather while maintaining its structural integrity and preventing water seepage effectively.

    Additionally, corrugated metal offers a more budget-friendly alternative compared to standing seam roofing, making it an appealing choice for homeowners mindful of their financial constraints. The availability of various colors allows for customization, enabling homeowners to synchronize their roofs with the overall aesthetic of their residences.

    In contrast, standing seam metal roofing emerges as a premium and exceptionally durable option. With its sleek, contemporary appearance and concealed fasteners, it eliminates the risks of corrosion or leakage over time. While providing superior protection against adverse weather conditions like strong winds, hail, and heavy snowfall, its installation process tends to be pricier due to additional labor requirements.

    Homeowner's Insurance and Roofing Material Choices

    New Franklin Roof Types

    In New Franklin, roof type choice can significantly impact your homeowner’s insurance coverage and costs. Variables like the longevity of the roofing material, susceptibility to weather-related damage, and maintenance needs play a vital role in determining insurance premiums. 

    This section will specifically address insurance considerations for two popular roof types—metal roofs and asphalt shingles. By understanding these factors, you can make a more informed decision about the roofing material for your home.

    Metal Roof Insurance Benefits

    Metal roofs may offer insurance benefits due to their durability and resistance to weather-related damage. Certain insurance companies may provide discounted rates for homes with metal roofs, given their increased durability and longer lifespan. Additionally, metal roofs can help reduce heating and cooling costs, resulting in energy savings that may further justify the higher initial cost of installation.

    Asphalt Shingle Insurance Considerations

    Asphalt shingle insurance considerations involve evaluating the material’s lifespan, maintenance requirements, and susceptibility to weather-related damage. Insurers factor in the type of roof and materials used when determining rebuild costs, resulting in different insurance premiums for homes with asphalt shingles compared to those with alternative roofing materials. 

    Coverage for roof damage, including scenarios where shingles are blown off or damaged by hail, varies depending on the severity and type of the damage. To gain a clear understanding of the specific coverage and considerations tied to asphalt shingles, it is advisable to have a discussion with your insurance provider.

    New Franklin Roof Types - Climate Considerations

    New Franklin Roof Types

    The local climate can have a significant impact on the performance and longevity of your roof type in New Franklin, OH. Extreme weather conditions such as:

    • heavy rain
    • snow
    • hail
    • high winds
    • extreme heat
    • humidity

    can hasten the wear and tear of your roof, impacting its longevity. It’s crucial to select a roof variety capable of enduring these climate challenges, safeguarding your residence, and ensuring a worthwhile investment in your roof. 

    Delving into the aspects of weather resilience and energy efficiency for both metal roofs and asphalt shingles, this exploration assists you in making an informed decision tailored to your home’s distinct climate conditions.

    Weather Resistance

    When it comes to weather resistance, metal roofs generally offer superior protection from extreme weather conditions, including:

    • Heavy rain
    • Snow
    • Hail
    • High winds
    • Extreme heat
    • Humidity

    For homeowners in regions with challenging climates, metal roofs emerge as the optimal choice. Unlike flat roofs and traditional asphalt shingles, metal roofs exhibit remarkable resilience to severe weather. Their ability to maintain integrity over time establishes them as a reliable and long-lasting solution, providing homeowners with confidence in their property’s protection.

    Energy Efficiency

    Opting for metal roofing over traditional asphalt shingles can result in enhanced energy efficiency, translating to notable savings on heating and cooling costs for homeowners. The reflective nature of metal roofs plays a pivotal role in reducing heat absorption during the summer, thereby decreasing the demand for cooling. 

    Conversely, asphalt shingles function as a reliable insulation material, maintaining comfortable indoor temperatures in winter and contributing to reduced heating expenses.

    New Franklin Roof Types - Making the Right Choice for Your Home with Pine Ridge Roofing

    New Franklin Roof Types

    When it comes to choosing the perfect roofing material, Pine Ridge Roofing has been a trusted advisor for over 25 years, aiding homeowners in selecting the right roof type in New Franklin, Ohio, and its environs. 

    Our specialization encompasses various roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles and metal roofs. Allow our experts to lead you through the process of evaluating your specific needs, ensuring that you make an informed decision in selecting the ideal roofing material for your home.

    Assessing Your Needs

    Selecting a roofing material involves considering various factors like:

    • Overall cost
    • Material weight
    • Local Weather
    • Architectural authenticity
    • Lifespan
    • Maintenance needs
    • Energy efficiency

    Tailoring your roofing choices to align with your preferences involves a thorough evaluation of key factors. When prioritizing an extended lifespan and minimal maintenance, a metal roof takes precedence. Conversely, if you value cost-effectiveness, style variety, and color options, asphalt shingles become a more appealing choice. 

    Pine Ridge Roofing professionals play a pivotal role in this decision-making process, bringing their expertise in diverse roofing materials, installation techniques, and local building codes to the table. Their guidance ensures that your final choice is well-informed and tailored precisely to suit your home.

    Consulting with Professionals at Pine Ridge Roofing

    Consulting with the professionals at Pine Ridge Roofing offers benefits such as:

    • Expert advice
    • Quality workmanship
    • Personalized attention
    • Transparent communication
    • Additional services such as seamless gutter replacement and repair

    We utilize only the finest materials and maintain stringent standards of workmanship, ensuring that your new Dutch gable roof, gable roof, flat roof, shed roof, or membrane roof is of superior quality and built to last by skilled roofing contractors.

    Pine Ridge Roofing offers free inspections and estimates, allowing you to make an informed decision about the best roofing material for your home without any financial commitment. Our competitive pricing and dedication to customer satisfaction make us an ideal choice for homeowners in New Franklin, Ohio, who are looking to invest in a high-quality, long-lasting roof.

    Summary

    In summary, the comparison between asphalt shingles and metal roofs reveals unique advantages and considerations for homeowners in New Franklin, Ohio. Asphalt shingles, known for their cost-effectiveness, durability, and diverse styles, stand in contrast to metal roofs, providing a resilient alternative with an extended lifespan and a variety of stylistic choices. Essential factors to weigh in the decision-making process include cost, longevity, maintenance, and architectural harmony.

    For personalized guidance that considers your specific needs, preferences, and local factors such as climate and building codes, Pine Ridge Roofing professionals are at your service. Trust in our expertise, exceptional craftsmanship, and individualized attention as you make a wise investment in a new roof, ensuring the ongoing protection and visual appeal of your home.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are the 3 main types of roofs?

    In New Franklin, roof types most common are hip, gable, and flat; each of which has its own advantages. Hip roofs are sloped on all sides while gable roofs have two sides that meet at the top to create a ridge. Flat roofs have an extremely low pitch and are nearly horizontal.

    Which type of roof is the most durable roof?

    For an enduring roof that stands the test of time, slate is the prime choice, boasting a remarkable lifespan exceeding 150 years. Another excellent option is clay tile, providing a durable solution with a lifespan of around 100 years.

    What roof design is the cheapest?

    A cost-effective approach to roof design involves adopting a hip roof without gables, a commonly favored construction method in the development of residential areas.

    What is the easiest roof to replace?

    Renowned for their affordability and simplicity in replacement, asphalt shingles take the lead in roofing solutions. Their lightweight composition allows for easy installation, typically managed by skilled professionals. Furthermore, their commendable durability ensures an average longevity of 30 years.

    What is the average lifespan of asphalt shingles compared to metal roofs?

    Asphalt shingles typically last around 30 years, while metal roofs have a much longer lifespan of up to 70 years.

    Scroll to Top